21 October 2013

Risk or Equalisation fees don't make sense

Greg ONeill
A 28 year industry veteran and CEO of La Trobe Financial, Greg O'Neill, has come out hard against the charging of risk or loan equalisation fees by specialist lending industry participants.

O'Neill who has worked at La Trobe Financial since 1984 has seen many changes to the industry over that time and states one concern he holds for the specialist lending sector future is not interest rates (at 30 year lows), unemployment, or whether there is or is not a housing bubble, but it is ...”the unnecessary practice of particular specialist lenders charging borrowers a “risk or equalisation fee” without providing any correlated borrower/consumer benefit”.

Interviewed recently on a range of industry issues, O’Neill stated there are three (3) things all brokers should now be asking before referring clients to any lender.

Broker Question 1: Is any Risk or Equalisation Fee being charged to my client?

It has become common practice for specialist lenders to charge borrowers "risk fees" (or sometimes called "equalisation fees") of up to 1.5 % and often 2% to obtain the loan in addition to the higher rate of interest offered. These amounts can add up to $4,000 or more on some loans.

Unlike Lenders Mortgage Insurance (LMI) offered by independent third party providers such as Genworth or QBE, these specialist lender risk or equalisation fees offer no consumer benefit or protection level at all for the borrower. LMI at least provides a bona fide independent contract of loss insurance for the lender, which in turn benefits the borrower from recovery actions of lenders to some extent. A risk or equalisation fee charged by specialist lenders is merely pocketed as profit.

This is why La Trobe Financial does not charge borrower clients a Risk or Equalisation Fee because unlike independent LMI, there is no tangible consumer benefit whatsoever in paying such risk or equalisation fees levied.

Broker Question 2: Am I putting my clients' interest first in referring them to this lender?

Some brokers could appear to be potentially conflicted by the very existence of such risk or equalisation fees without knowing it. It appears payment of these 'Risk or equalisation Fees' may assist the chosen lender to pay the referring broker a higher upfront loan origination fee.

A fundamental basis of the current National Consumer Credit Protection Act (NCCP) was to ensure borrowers could easily compare loans, make informed choice, and be represented independently and impartially by their broker as their agent. In fact a broker's independence is the cornerstone of the business case for using a loan broker rather than consumers dealing with the lender directly.

The NCCP at section 47(1)(b) states brokers (credit representatives) ...”must not put the borrower at a disadvantage” and placing a client into a loan with a risk or equalisation fee from which you are sharing could be an argument to be prosecuted as a breach of general conduct obligations.

Simply put, the broker must always place the borrower's interest above their own in receiving remuneration. So in O’Neill’s view the question all brokers should be asking is...”are my clients being charged a risk or equalisation fee, and what benefit do the borrowers receive from that fee versus what benefit I as the broker am receiving or is there an alternative provider”.

Broker Question 3: Is there a better alternative?

Regrettably the handful of remaining specialist lenders (also referred to as nonconforming or near prime), were deeply buffeted by the GFC due to increased costs associated with reliance on capital market securitisation funding, and they also had to contend with the Federal Government’s decision by Wayne Swan in December 2010 to axe loan exit fees in an effort to increase competition. This resulted in, if not all, then most specialist lenders adopting a front end loaded “risk or equalisation fee” structure on all loan products to compensate for their lower overall profitability and to comply with the new legislative push.

Ironically the current market outcome and distortion were foreseen by the May 2011 Senate Economics Committee inquiry into “Competition in the Banking Sector” which stated the exit fee ban could lead to higher upfront fees and reduce competition. The committee stated in its report... “The committee recommends that the government reconsider its decision to ban exit fees, before the amended regulations come into effect, with a view to allowing enough time for the effectiveness of the existing ban on unfair and unconscionable exit fees ... to be assessed.” The absolute ban on loan exit fees of any amount has given rise to this current “risk or equalisation fee anomaly” resulting in no consumer benefit and several sector distortions. Unfortunately common sense did not prevail and the legislation was enacted with much fanfare about saving consumers.

Now whilst O’Neill is the first to admit the specialist sector is small (circa $2billion of new loan volume per annum), it nonetheless remains an important sector of the much larger total $1.3trillion residential lending market in Australia which is dominated by mainstream bank lenders and is a significant contributor to broader economic activity and small businesses across the country.

Its importance cannot be over-stated as the specialist sector has always served with distinction a high preponderance of self employed borrowers or those with minor credit blemishes, who through such specialist credit providers have an opportunity to build consistent loan repayment profiles and history, enabling them to refinance and join mainstream credit providers at a later point, and without whom such borrowers would be forced to deal with unlicensed and unregistered private operators and/or much higher interest rate payday lenders.

“Our organisation”, says O’Neill, “has for over 60 years served this sector with distinction and we understand such clients' situations when dealing with them”. In an endeavour to assist its clients understand the borrowing process further, La Trobe Financial was the first in Australia to have developed a consumer advisory guide which has been issued to all loan applicants for the past seven years entitled “When Borrowing Doesn’t Add Up” warning clients to ensure they can afford the loan and to avoid unnecessary charges which provide no benefit when dealing with lenders and to shop around. “We do not and have not charged “Risk or Equalisation Fees” on any of our loan products” says O’Neill.

On one view dealing with a lender who doesn’t charge risk or equalisation fees can benefit the consumer simply because the broker is no longer potentially conflicted. “What we are increasingly seeing is the good brokers are now really asking the question about risk or equalisation fees relevance and benefit, as they are truly understanding the business importance of representing the interests of their borrowing clients first” said O’Neill.

Why use La Trobe Financial to borrow money?

  • Flexibility
    La Trobe Financial is accepted as one of the leading players in the specialist lending space in Australia. We are not a 'tick the box' type lender, but will consider all of a borrower’s personal circumstances fairly and compassionately. Borrowers can also choose the length of their loan that best suits their needs, with our flexible repayment schedules.

  • Approachable & Reasonable
    We approve mortgage loans for any reasonable purposes including helping people with debt consolidation. So if borrowers need a mortgage loan from as little as $100,000 up to $5 million, or simply need to get their debts under control, we can help.

  • Make Extra Repayments and FREE Redraw
    We provide a free redraw service for repayments received ahead of schedule.

  • Simple Application Process
    Borrowers can fill out our Application Form today. It only takes 15 minutes to apply for a mortgage loan at La Trobe Financial; it’s that simple. And if borrowers need a hand completing the application, just ask one of our friendly staff – they’ll be happy to help.

  • Speed of Approval
    We can tell brokers or borrowers, ‘on the spot’ whether the application for a mortgage loan can been accepted with indicative approval.

  • Dedicated Broker Hot desk
    You won’t be talking to an answering machine at La Trobe Financial; with representatives across Australia, and our 1800 707 707 National Hotline open 8:30am to 5:30pm Mon-Fri you will be personally assisted with your loan application from start to finish. Simply call – no need for an appointment. Speak to any of our national Sales or Credit teams shown here.

  • No Commision Clawback
    We explicitly agree that no clawback of your brokerage trail commission or upfront fee share will occur for loans that refinance to another lender. This revenue protection clause looks after you and your client.

  • Experience credit authorised BDMs
    Local BDMs who can visit your office that have credit limit approval authority and can educate you on our Award winning Investment Fund Products.

  • No Risk or Equalisation fees
    We don't charge a Risk or Equalisation fee.

... That's Lending

Best regards,
Paul Wells, Chief Investment Officer
La Trobe Financial Asset Origination & Credit Division

La Trobe Financial is one of Australia's leading independent credit specialist Fund Managers. Its business includes residential mortgages, commercial mortgages, and investment services operating one of Australia's largest Mortgage Funds under AFSL 222213. It employs over 123 staff and has managed over AUD$10Billion covering over 100,000 investment grade assets since inception in 1952.

Copyright 2013 La Trobe Financial. All rights reserved. No portion of this may be reproduced, copied, or in any way reused without written permission from La Trobe Financial. Disclaimer

The following awards and ratings were given to the Pooled Mortgage Option within the La Trobe Financial Mortgage Fund and may be viewed on our website

Ratings And Awards
Click to share

> Loan Products
> Partner Portal
> Subscribe Free

Paul Wells
Snr Vice President
Chief Investment Officer

(03) 8610 2802

Senior Manager's Client Partnership (SCMP)
Daryl Hill
0408 566 524
Vice President
Head of Major Clients
Craig Robertson
0447 599 664
Head of Sales
– Credit
Sally Humprhis
Exec. Head of Institutional Sales
0448 404 413
Suzanne Hemsworth
0421 029 691

Sam Deeby
0419 114 790

Janelle Barnes
0409 435 559

Nicole Waugh
0438 637 490

Robyn Eacott
0459 056 760

Megan Pfab
0408 126 664

Michael Watson
0409 419 039

Paul Biddle
0421 029 687

David Sturtevant
0414 451 031

Michelle Bannister
0408 566 518

Credit Approval
Cory Bannister
03 5177 1606
Head of Product
– Credit
Steve Lawrence
03 8610 2807
Head of Underwriting
– Credit
Ryan Harkness
03 8610 2856
Head of Debt
Capital Markets

Justin Coates
03 8610 2882
Head of Operations
– Credit
Luke Jones
Credit Manager
03 8610 2816
Jimmy Mc Grath
Credit Analyst
03 8610 2846
Louise Lindeman
Credit Analyst
03 8610 2827
Gerald Edwards
Credit Analyst
03 8610 2879
Linda Gorski
Asset Retention Manager
03 8610 2817
Bianca Williams
Credit Analyst
03 8610 2877
Daniel Sudjaya
Credit Analyst
03 8610 2880
Garry Skelton
Credit Analyst
03 8610 2832
Kelly Tierney
Asset Retention
03 8610 2822
Laura Henderson
Asset Retention
03 8610 2836
Loan Closer Team
Leanne Seymour
Loan Closer Unit Manager
03 8610 2808
Marrisa Hoffman
Senior Loan Closer Unit
03 8610 2824
Sakshi Goyal
Loan Closer Unit
03 8610 2826
Newsletter Footer

Please Note: This publication is for accredited broker use only and is not for distribution to consumers.

All loan applications are fully assessed to ensure the loan is not unsuitable and that we meet our responsible lending obligations in accordance with our usual underwriting requirements. All features and interest rates are current as at the date of publication. Conditions, fees and charges apply. This message, together with the La Trobe Financial website (www.latrobefinancial.com.au) and all its contents have been prepared for general information only and should not be taken as legal or financial advice, and as such the specific needs, investment objectives or financial situation of any particular user have not been taken into consideration. Individuals should therefore talk with their financial planner or advisor before acting on any information present on this message or the La Trobe website. La Trobe Financial Asset Management Limited ABN: 27 007 332 363 and AFSL No: 222213 is the issuer and manager of the La Trobe Australian Mortgage Fund. It is important for you to read the Product Disclosure Statement for the Fund before you make any investment decision. You can get a copy of the PDS by calling 1800 818 818. You should consider carefully whether or not investing in the Fund is appropriate for you. The rates of return from the Fund are not guaranteed and are determined by future revenue of the Fund, and may achieve lower than expected returns. Investors risk losing some or all of their principal investment. The investment is not a bank deposit.

La Trobe Financial Services Pty Limited - Australian Credit Licence Number: 392385
La Trobe Financial Asset Management Limited - Australian Credit Licence Number: 222213

Terms, conditions, fees, charges and La Trobe Financial lending criteria apply.

1. Zenith's "recommended" rating indicates that it has high confidence in the manager meeting its objectives. The Zenith Investment Partners ("Zenith") ABN 60 332 047 314 rating referred to in this document is limited to "General Advice" (as defined by section 766B of Corporations Act 2001) and based solely on the assessment of the investment merits of the financial product on this basis. It is not a specific recommendation to purchase, sell or hold the relevant product(s), and Zenith advises that individual investors should seek their own independent financial advice before investing in this product. To view the relevant research information, please visit www.latrobefinancial.com.au The rating is subject to change without notice and Zenith has no obligation to update this document following publication. Zenith usually receives a fee for rating the fund manager and product against accepted criteria considered comprehensive and objective.
2. SQM Research - 4 stars to 4.25 stars - superior, suitable for inclusion on most Approved Product Lists. To view the relevant research information, please visit www.latrobefinancial.com.au This rating will not take into account your, or your clients' objectives, financial situation or needs. It is up to investors to consider whether specific financial products are suitable for your objectives, financial situation or needs. Research houses receive a fee from La Trobe Financial for rating the product.
3. Lipper Leaders Rating Total Return (Score – 5) Lipper Ratings for Total Return reflect funds’ historical return performance relative to peers. The ratings are subject to change every month. The highest 20% of funds in each peer group are named Lipper Leader or a score of 5 for Total Return. Lipper Leader ratings are not intended to predict future results and does not guarantee the accuracy of this information. More information is available at www.lipperweb.com. Thomson Reuters Copyright, All Rights Reserved.
4. Australia Ratings (AFSL 346138) makes every effort to ensure the reliability of the views and rankings expressed in its reports and those published on its websites. Australia Ratings research is based upon information known to it or which was obtained from sources it believed to be reliable and accurate at time of publication. However, like the markets, it is not perfect. This report is prepared for general information only, and as such, the specific needs, investment objectives or financial situation of any particular user have not been taken into consideration. Individuals should therefore discuss, with their financial planner or advisor, the merits of each rating for their own specific circumstances and realise that not all investments will be appropriate for all subscribers. To the extent permitted by law, Australia Ratings and its employees, agents and authorised representatives exclude all liability for any loss or damage (including indirect, special or consequential loss or damage) arising from the use of, or reliance on, any information within the report whether or not caused by any negligent act or omission. If the law prohibits the exclusion of such liability, Australia Ratings hereby limits its liability, to the extent permitted by law, to the resupply of the said information or the cost of the said resupply.